Dermatology nursing in a rural area - the Overberg experience
Community dermatology in a rural area in the Western Cape.
Operational Manager, Overberg District, Western Cape, South Africa
The Overberg District Municipality of the Western Cape stretches over 11 391 km2 along the coastline from Kleinmond in the west to Witsand in the east and from Villiersdorp and Barrydale in the north to Struisbaai in the south (Fig. 1).
The district covers the 4 municipalities of Cape Agulhas, Overstrand, Swellendam and Theewaterskloof and has a population of 247 684, according to the last census. There are 28 clinics, 14 mobile clinics, 4 satellite clinics and 4 district hospitals, which receive provincial government help. Notably, there is one maternity obstetric unit, and there are no TB hospitals, psychiatric hospitals, or regional hospital services in the area.
I am stationed at Elim Clinic in the Cape Agulhas Municipality.
In 2007, I responded to an advertisement in the Nursing News, a magazine of the
Democratic Nursing Organisation of South Africa (DENOSA), and
registered for the 2-month dermatology nurse short course at
Groote Schuur Hospital. On completion of the course I returned
to the Overberg with the mission of implementing a dermatology
nurse-led service and clinics in the area.
The Overberg dermatology nurse-led service
The following is an overview of the highs and lows of establishing this dermatology nursing service at primary healthcare level in the rural areas of the Cape Agulhas and Swellendam sub-districts of the Overberg District from 2008 to 2013.
The aims of the service were:
• to provide adequate dermatology care at level 1 healthcare clinics
• to limit the burden of disease on the healthcare system by improving diagnosis of skin disease and providing appropriate skin care
• to improve referral patterns to/from secondary and tertiary institutions
• to provide a holistic approach to patient care
• to promote skin health at all levels
• to offer prevention and management of skin conditions to the individual, family and community
• to ensure the sustainability of the dermatology service.
In 2008, I managed to negotiate a dermatology service for clinics in the Cape Agulhas municipal area – Bredasdorp, Elim, Struisbaai, Waenhuiskrans/Arniston and Napier. These were small beginnings because, as a general clinical nurse practioner at Elim Clinic, time was limited for developing specialist services. Eventually, with the help of a government car, I was able to start monthly services, on a Friday, at these clinics, where 25 patients were seen per session.
In 2009, because of the success of the Agulhas municipal area clinics, I could expand the service to clinics in the Swellendam municipal area, namely Swellendam and Barrydale (Fig. 2). More recently, dermatology services were extended to Suurbraak Clinic in the same municipality. These clinics service a population of approximately 45 000 (Table 1).
In all areas clinical nurse practioner-led mobile services are routinely provided to the largely farming communities. These monthly mobile clinics are all held on farms. Dermatology services are now included as part of these clinic services by generalist clinical nurse practioners.
Despite running dermatology services at 8 clinics in the Overberg area, clinics are still held only once a month but have been extended to 2 days – a Thursday and a Friday.
Most patients are referred to the dermatology clinic by their
local clinical nurse practioner or by medical officers.
Referrals are also received from local general practitioners
from as far afield as Heidelberg.
Fig. 2. Sister Delena and students outside the Barrydale Clinic.
Referral and follow-up
The referral pathways from the Overberg dermatology clinics are to the district hospitals for biopsies and specialist tertiary services for further management.
Cellphone teledermatology consultations take place with specialists from tertiary dermatology services; this provides an excellent triage tool for quicker, more precise diagnosis and management. Patients can be started on appropriate treatment immediately without having to return to the clinic and, if necessary, they can be referred for treatments not available at the clinics or in the case of emergencies.
Because of the intermittent nature of the service, follow-up of dermatology patients seen at the various clinics is provided by the referring healthcare worker. This has resulted in up-skilling of the generalists in the clinics in keeping with government policy of improving basic training before providing specialist services.
Data are captured on a daily basis via routine monthly reports and then forwarded on a monthly basis for verification ‒ first at sub-district and then at district level ‒ before capture on the Sinjani system. Dermatology data currently do not form part of the information system but separate data are forwarded.
Spectrum of skin disease
From January to June 2012, a total of 502 patients were seen at the dermatology clinics, with an average of 20 cases per clinic. Fifteen per cent of the patients were less than 5 years of age and the predominant skin disease was atopic eczema.
Common skin diseases seen at the clinics are listed in Table 2. Contrary to expectations, infections and infestations were in the minority; chronic diseases, such as eczema, psoriasis and vitiligo, predominated. This implies that common conditions expected at primary care level are being managed by generalists, or patients self-medicate and do not seek help. The predominance of chronic skin diseases highlights the gap in community healthcare that is now being appropriately filled by the consulting specialist nurse service.
The spectrum of skin disease varies from site to site and is potentially important for healthcare provision and planning. For example, vitiligo, tinea versicolor, acne and tinea capitus predominated at the Barrydale Clinic over this period.
The referral of unusual and chronic diseases to the dermatology
nursing sister meant that cases were diagnosed and treated
early. Examples of tertiary referrals from the Bredasdorp Clinic
were 3 cases of acne keloidalis referred for curative surgical
excision and 2 cases of chronic discoid lupus erythematosus
referred for exclusion of systemic disease and initiation of
Examples of the more complex cases seen over this period are shown in Fig. 3, which is a collage of cases of abnormal pigmentation seen at clinics and managed by referral or teledermatology consultation.
The essential drug list for primary care dermatology is very
limited (Table 3). When the dermatology service started, limited
stock of topical agents needed to treat chronic skin disease was
available, largely because no one ‘owned’ the service. Since
then, an effective and collegial relationship has developed with
local pharmacies, resulting in an increased range and supply of
medication to cope with down-referrals.
Fig. 3. Complex disorders of dyspigmentation seen at the Overberg clinics. A. Whorled hypopigmentation on the trunk of a patient with hypomelanosis of Ito. B. Macules of depigmentation in a phyllatoid pattern in a patient with vitiligo. C. Periorbital erythema, hypopigmentation and scale in a patient with presumed atypical psoriasis. D. Verrucous black nodule with rim of blue-black pigmentation confirmed as a verrucous nodular melanoma.
Dissemination of dermatology knowledge and skills acquired among the rest of the Overberg healthcare providers is central to the dermatology service. Common primary care skin problems are already effectively managed at the general clinics. Because the clinics can only be held intermittently, knowledge acquired by generalists who provide follow-up care in between clinics has improved dramatically.
The clinics have become important teaching nodes for the University of Cape Town (UCT)’s 5th-year MB ChB students who spend 2 days in the area as part of their dermatology training (mixed specialty block) (Fig. 4). Clinics are visited in rotation and provide ongoing medical education for local healthcare providers.
The clinics are central to the Postgraduate Diploma in Dermatology nurse training. Students spend 2 weeks in the area as part of their community and environmental dermatology module. A report of their experiences and how it will aid them in the establishment of a similar service in their communities forms part of the formative assessment. The first two graduates were stationed at Elim in 2012.
The monthly outreach services provided by UCT to the Overberg
region, with clinics visited in rotation approximately twice a
year, provide my only in-service continuing medical education
The outcomes of the Overberg dermatology nurse-led service have been numerous and include the following:
For the Department of Health:
• It has limited the burden on the tertiary healthcare system.
• It has reduced the financial expenditure on transport.
• Biopsies are done at the local hospital via the knoppie-lys.
• Attendance numbers at dermatology outreach visits have decreased.
• Adequate pharmacological supplies are now ensured.
• Bed utilisation is reduced by providing community facility-based care.
For the individual patient:
• Monthly specialist services are available.
• Monthly follow-up appointments are available.
• Changes in skin condition are recognised and managed early.
• Patients are encouraged to seek medical assistance sooner, as it is available on their doorstep.
• They no longer have to be ashamed of white spots (wit kolle), ringworms and warts, as these are now effectively managed and not ignored as being ‘cosmetic problems’.
• Interpersonal relationships of healthcare workers with individual patients are possible.
• Healthcare workers can motivate better adherence to treatment options.
• Holidaymakers to the coastal resorts make use of the service.
• General practitioners refer patients.
Staff of the Overberg health service:
• They are provided with education and training opportunities.
• They are provided with immediate referral responses.
• They have accessibility to telemedicine consultations.
• The workload of the clinical nurse practioners is reduced.
• They act as partners in a multidisciplinary health team.
For dermatology nurse practioners:
• They are empowered with dermatology knowledge and skills.
• They are empowered to assess and make an appropriate diagnosis of a magnitude of skin conditions.
• They are empowered to appropriately manage a magnitude of skin conditions.
• They are equipped with skills in the application and use of various pharmacological preparations.
• They are equipped to provide the necessary health education and promotion to decrease the defaulter rate.
• They are equipped to provide dermatology education to colleagues.
• They observe best practices of other PHC facilities.
• They meet people from a variety of backgrounds.
• There is job satisfaction through patient satisfaction and gratitude.
Challenges and recommendations
We have established a functioning dermatology service in the Overberg region which is based on rotational dermatology nurse consultations. Attendance at clinics has increased and is expected to increase further once patients are aware of the extent and quality of the services offered. The main challenge it faces is sustainability. Succession planning is an important component of the service. We need to encourage and awaken an interest in dermatology among nurses who have had little or no previous exposure and whose training has essentially ignored the plight of those with skin disease.
Dermatology treatment requires special skills in the ‘how’ of topical treatment. To encourage patient adherence we need to provide day care infrastructure for nursing interventions at facility level. This will enable clinic staff to manage patients acutely and provide education on topical use.
Improved dermatology data capturing will provide the necessary statistics to motivate for improvements in services, staff and facilities. This needs to be addressed as a priority.
More regular dermatology clinics and local healthcare centre teaching need to be offered by the clinical nurse practioner. In view of the vast distances travelled currently, it would seem advisable to provide an increase in suitably trained dermatology clinical nurse practioners at strategic clinics. These could be specialist nurses or clinical nurse practioners with a special interest in dermatology.
Mentorship of dermatology nursing students should continue as an essential component of the service.
Support for dermatology nurses should be provided via the Dermatology Nursing Support Group. This has already been initiated and will form a sub-committee of the Dermatological Association of South Africa. It is already affiliated to the International Skin Nurse Group, a full member of the International League of Dermatology Societies.
Full text views: 3802